The Death of Buy-to-Let: Is It Time to Explore New Investment Avenues?

The buy-to-let (BTL) market, once a lucrative investment avenue, may be nearing its end. For the past three decades, professional and mature landlords have reaped substantial returns on capital, thanks to two key factors: leverage and capital growth. These two multipliers have worked hand-in-hand—more leverage increased demand, which in turn drove capital appreciation. The baby boomer generation has been the primary beneficiary of this trend, often proclaiming, “You can’t lose on property.” While this statement has held true for the last 30 years, significant changes are now on the horizon that could disrupt the BTL market as we know it.

The Impact of Aggressive Tax Changes

Recent tax reforms introduced by the Conservative Government are poised to significantly affect the BTL market. These changes, designed to curb the advantages of BTL investments, will have a profound impact, particularly on those who rely heavily on mortgage financing.

Phasing Out of Mortgage Interest Relief:

One of the most significant changes is the phased reduction of mortgage interest relief, which began in the 2017/18 tax year. By 2020, landlords could only claim basic rate tax relief on their mortgage interest payments. Let’s consider an example to understand the impact:

A landlord with an 80% loan-to-value (LTV) mortgage receives £10,000 in rent annually and pays £8,000 in interest. Under the old system, on a £2,000 profit, they would pay 40% tax (£800), leaving a net gain of £1,200. However, under the new system, tax is calculated on turnover minus a 20% tax credit. 40% of £10,000 is £4,000. The relief amounts to 20% of the interest (£8,000 × 20% = £1,600), resulting in a £2,400 tax bill. When you add this to the mortgage interest, a previous annual profit of £1,200 turns into a loss of £400.

This example highlights the drastic effect of the tax changes, especially on landlords with high levels of leverage.

Building a Rental Empire? The Challenges of 2024

The rental sector faces a daunting year ahead. For landlords aiming to survive in 2024, there are three essential strategies they must adopt:

1. **Adapt Your Portfolio:** Landlords need to reassess their portfolios in light of new tax policies and rising interest rates. Diversifying into different regions or types of properties may offer better yields and stability.

2. **Increase Rents Strategically:** As costs rise, passing some of these onto tenants may be necessary. The Telegraph’s Secret Landlord recently increased rents by 12 percent, noting that despite the hike, tenants still got a bargain. This underscores the importance of pricing rental properties appropriately to maintain profitability.

3. **Explore Alternative Investment Structures:** With traditional BTL becoming less attractive, landlords should consider setting up company structures to hold properties or explore property bonds as an alternative investment avenue.

Additionally, if Labour comes into power, owning rental property could become even more costly, potentially squeezing margins further. For ongoing insights and advice, landlords should follow the regular *Secret Landlord* column in The Telegraph, which provides a candid view of the joys and challenges of being a landlord.

The Areas Where Landlords Are Keeping Britain’s Buy-to-Let Alive

Despite the mounting challenges in the BTL market, some investors are bucking the trend and expanding their portfolios in specific areas where rental yields remain robust.

Investors Knuckle Down Despite High Interest Rates and Regulation:**

Many landlords are exiting the BTL market due to high interest rates, reduced tax relief, and the increasing regulatory burden. However, for some, like 28-year-old Ryan Cresswell, this is an opportunity rather than a deterrent. Cresswell, who owns 13 properties across Darlington, has bought four more properties in 2024 and continues to seek new deals. “I’m massively actively buying. I really want to grow my portfolio,” says Cresswell, who treats his investments as a long-term business venture.

Despite the downturn in BTL property purchases overall, certain areas in the UK are witnessing growth in rental property demand. Middlesbrough leads the way, with 40% of all residential purchases going to landlords, followed by Derby at 35%, Peterborough at 33%, and Darlington and York at 30%. These regions recorded rent rises of 6% or more in July 2024 compared to the previous year, according to the Office for National Statistics.

Landlords are drawn to these areas by consistently high yields—9% in Middlesbrough and nearby Darlington, compared to the UK average of 7.3%. The strong rental growth combined with stagnant property prices has made these regions attractive for new investors, many of whom are not local but are enticed by the potential returns.

**A Shift in Investor Focus:**
The changing appetite of investors is evident in London, where the proportion of London-based investors buying BTL properties in the capital has dropped from 62% in 2014 to 32% in 2024. Investors have become more yield-focused, shifting their attention to more affordable regions with higher returns.

Estate agents report that BTL properties are increasingly being acquired by investors who treat it as a business, as opposed to amateur landlords who struggle with rising regulation. The introduction of the three percentage point stamp duty surcharge on second homes and the reduction in mortgage interest tax relief have pushed many landlords to set up limited companies for their investments, allowing them to retain some tax benefits.

**A New Breed of Landlords:**
Younger landlords like Cresswell represent a new breed of investor—savvy, educated, and prepared to navigate the complexities of the BTL market. Many have taken courses on how to be successful property investors, learning about return on investment, yield optimisation, and the benefits of setting up limited companies. This new wave of investors often shares their journey on social media, documenting property transformations and investment strategies.

Cresswell himself documents his BTL experiences on TikTok and Instagram, where he shares lessons and insights with a growing audience. “I would love to help more people get into this,” he says, reflecting a broader trend among younger investors who are redefining the BTL landscape.

### The Changing Landscape of BTL

The high property prices in the South East, combined with compressed rental yields, make the traditional BTL model increasingly unviable. The days of easy profits through BTL may be over, especially as new tax burdens and the potential for rising interest rates erode profitability.

**Market Impact:**
We are already seeing signs of major landlords liquidating their portfolios. For instance, Britain’s largest BTL investors recently sold their entire portfolio of 1,000 properties to a private cash investor from the Middle East. This mass sell-off is likely to flood the market with properties, putting downward pressure on prices. Additionally, the slowdown in foreign investment from China, Russia, and the Middle East—driven by the end of the commodity supercycle—could further dampen property prices, particularly in the South East.

### Alternatives to Traditional BTL

While the BTL model may no longer be as attractive, opportunities still exist in other regions and investment vehicles. Northern England, particularly areas within the “Northern Powerhouse,” continues to offer higher yields and potential for capital growth, driven by significant foreign direct investment (FDI).

**Property Bonds: A New Investment Avenue:**
One emerging alternative is property bonds. These bonds allow property developers to raise capital outside of traditional banking channels. Here’s how it works:

Suppose a property developer wants to buy an existing commercial building in central Manchester, intending to convert it into high-end apartments. The developer issues a bond at a 10% annual return to investors, raising the £5 million needed for the project. The building costs £4 million, and redevelopment costs £1 million. By changing the building’s usage under permitted development rights and incorporating energy-efficient technologies, the developer increases the property’s value to nearly £10 million. The developer can then refinance the property with a bank, fully covering the initial investment and repaying the bondholders.

This model offers several advantages:
– **Tax Efficiency:** Large corporate structures can mitigate many of the taxes that individual BTL landlords incur.
– **Hands-Free Investment:** Property bonds offer a hands-off approach, with no need for investors to manage properties, handle tenants, or cover maintenance costs.
– **Attractive Returns:** A 10% return on capital employed is often net of all fees, overheads, and financing costs—unlike the traditional BTL model.

Many of these bonds are also SIPP-approved, making them more tax-efficient than traditional BTL investments. However, it’s important to conduct thorough due diligence. The security of a bond depends on the credibility of the development team and the assets backing the bond. Investors should look for a well-established trustee to manage the project and ensure the bond is secured against tangible assets like existing property or land.

### Conclusion: A New Era for Property Investors

For existing BTL landlords, it’s crucial to reassess the viability of their portfolios in light of the new tax landscape. For those seeking alternatives, property bonds offer a compelling option, especially for those looking for less hands-on investment opportunities. As the property market evolves, adapting to these changes will be key to maintaining and growing wealth.

At Willow Rivers, we offer a wide range of structured investments, including property bonds. We welcome the opportunity to discuss how these investment vehicles work, their potential returns, associated risks, and how they can be integrated into a diverse portfolio.

—